Paubha Paintings: Nepal’s Sacred Artistic Heritage

Paubha: A Sacred Canvas of the Kathmandu Valley

A. Defining Paubha: More Than Just a Painting

Paubhā (Devanagari: पौभा) is a traditional form of religious painting created by the Newar people of Nepal, indigenous to the historic Kathmandu Valley.¹ These intricate artworks typically depict deities, mandalas, or sacred monuments and are primarily intended to aid practitioners in their meditation and spiritual observances.¹ The very name “Paubhā” is believed to be a derivative of the Sanskrit term ‘Patrabhattaraka,’ where ‘Patra’ signifies sheets or paper, and ‘Bhattaraka’ represents gods and goddesses. Together, this translates to “divine in flat form,” underscoring the profound belief that these paintings are not mere representations but are imbued with the sacred presence of the depicted divinities.² This etymology offers a direct window into the core function and esteemed status of Paubha: it is conceived as a tangible manifestation of the divine on a two-dimensional plane, transforming the artwork into a holy object in its own right.

A defining characteristic of Paubha art is its unique embrace of both Hindu and Buddhist traditions, a feature that distinguishes it significantly from its Tibetan counterpart, the Thangka, which is exclusively associated with Buddhist art.¹ This inclusivity is a direct reflection of the centuries-old religious syncretism prevalent in the Kathmandu Valley, where Hindu and Buddhist philosophies have long coexisted, intertwined, and mutually influenced one another.² Thus, Paubha paintings serve as a vibrant visual testament to this harmonious spiritual landscape, often featuring deities and symbols from both pantheons. The paintings are deeply imbued with symbolism, acting as powerful mediums for religious storytelling, the transmission of complex spiritual philosophies, and as focal points for devotional practices.² They are designed to be more than aesthetically pleasing objects; they are functional spiritual tools intended to guide practitioners on their path to enlightenment and deepen their connection with the divine.⁵ The dual Hindu-Buddhist nature of Paubha, therefore, is not simply an iconographic curiosity but a profound expression of the Newar worldview and the unique religious history of Nepal, making these artworks a singular lens through which to understand the region’s spiritual identity.

B. Origins and the Newar Legacy: The Keepers of a Divine Art

The genesis of Paubha art is inextricably linked to the Newar people, the indigenous community of the Kathmandu Valley, particularly within its ancient and culturally vibrant cities of Patan, Bhaktapur, and Kathmandu.¹ These urban centres have historically been crucibles of artistic and religious innovation, providing fertile ground for the development of Paubha’s distinct style. Traditionally, the creation of these sacred paintings has been the domain of specific Newar castes, most notably the Chitrakar caste, also known as ‘Pun’ in the Nepal Bhasa language.¹

The precise timeline for the origins of Paubha art is a subject of ongoing scholarly discussion, though it is generally traced back to a period between the 11th and 13th centuries.¹ Some art historians suggest even earlier roots, potentially extending into the Licchavi period (circa 4th to 9th centuries CE), a golden age of artistic and religious flourishing in Nepal.² The scarcity of surviving examples from these very early periods is largely attributed to the inherent fragility of the cloth medium upon which they were painted and the traditional practice of ritually replacing old or damaged Paubhas with new ones.² This custom, while ensuring the continuity of the art form, has inadvertently limited the pool of ancient specimens available for study.

The hereditary nature of Paubha painting, often passed down within Chitrakar families from father to son or from master (guru) to disciple (sisya), signifies that these artists are more than just skilled craftspeople.¹ They are the living repositories of an immense body of traditional knowledge, encompassing not only artistic techniques but also complex iconographic rules, the meticulous processes of preparing materials, and the performance of essential rituals.⁸ This transmission of knowledge, often kept within the family or a close circle of initiates, underscores the Chitrakars’ role as custodians of both the tangible and intangible heritage of Paubha art. The Kathmandu Valley, with its rich artistic milieu, thus served not merely as a birthplace for Paubha but as a dynamic centre of artistic creation and dissemination. The exceptional skill of Newar artists was renowned throughout the Himalayan region and even as far as China, leading to Newar artists and merchants playing a pivotal role in introducing the art form to Tibet, where it subsequently influenced the evolution of the Tibetan Thangka.¹ This positions the Kathmandu Valley as a key artistic hub that actively shaped the visual culture of the broader Himalayan region.

A Journey Through Time: The History of Paubha Art

A. Echoes of the Ancients: From Licchavi Roots to Malla Flourishing

The historical roots of Paubha painting are thought to extend deep into Nepal’s past, with many scholars believing its genesis lies in the Licchavi period (circa 4th to 9th centuries CE).² This era was characterised by significant artistic and religious dynamism in the Kathmandu Valley, fostered in part by the close cultural and political ties between the Licchavi rulers and the Gupta Empire in India.¹⁰ This interaction facilitated a rich exchange of ideas and artistic styles, laying a foundational layer for subsequent Newar artistic traditions.

While direct physical evidence of Paubha from the Licchavi era is scarce, the earliest surviving specimens that scholars have identified date primarily from the 11th century onwards. Among these, a Paubha depicting Amitabha Buddha, now housed in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, is widely considered one of the earliest known examples, stylistically dated to the 11th century (Nepal Sambat 485).¹ Other early forms of Newar painting that share stylistic and thematic similarities with Paubha include illuminated manuscript covers from the 11th century and a notable Chakrasamvara Mandala dated to circa 1100.¹⁰ The existence of these early works suggests that the artistic conventions and iconographic language of Paubha were well-established by this period. It is plausible that the tradition of painting on cloth (Paubha) evolved from the earlier practice of illustrating manuscript covers, adapting the established styles to a larger, more public format while maintaining a continuity of religious subject matter, particularly deities from the Mahayana Buddhist pantheon.¹⁰

The Malla period, spanning from the 12th to the 18th centuries, is widely regarded as a zenith for Newar art and culture, and Paubha painting flourished significantly during this time.¹¹ The patronage of Malla kings, influential Buddhist monasteries, and wealthy merchant families provided the necessary stability and resources for artists to create increasingly sophisticated and elaborate works.¹¹ This era saw the refinement of Paubha techniques and the production of numerous masterpieces, many of which were commissioned not only for their aesthetic beauty but also as acts of religious merit and for use in important rituals and ceremonies.

B. Influences and Exchanges: Connections with Indian and Tibetan Traditions

The artistic landscape of early Paubha was significantly shaped by influences from the south, particularly from the Pala dynasty of Eastern India (circa 750-1150 A.D.).¹ Surviving early Paubhas exhibit such strong stylistic resemblances to Pala paintings that distinguishing between them can be an academic challenge, indicating a profound artistic dialogue and shared cultural sphere across the Indo-Nepalese border during this period.¹⁰ This connection highlights how the Kathmandu Valley was an integral part of a larger network of Indic artistic traditions.

Conversely, Newar artistic traditions, particularly Paubha painting, exerted considerable influence northward into Tibet. Newar artists and merchants were instrumental in carrying their artistic skills and religious paintings into Tibet, where these traditions played a foundational role in the development of Tibetan Thangka painting.¹ For a significant period, spanning roughly three to four hundred years, Nepal was a key disseminator of artistic and cultural trends into the Himalayan region, with its influence extending far beyond its borders.¹⁰ This underscores the high esteem in which Newar artists were held and their pivotal role in shaping the visual culture of Tibetan Buddhism.

Over time, this artistic exchange became more reciprocal. Later, Paubha paintings began to incorporate elements that suggest Tibetan influence, such as certain mythological animals and motifs associated with shamanistic beliefs prevalent in the Tibetan cultural sphere.¹ By the 17th century, Tibetan artists had synthesised Nepalese, Chinese, and indigenous Tibetan elements to create their own distinct and highly developed Thangka styles.¹⁰ This dynamic interplay of influences demonstrates the vibrant and evolving nature of artistic traditions across the Himalayas, where ideas and motifs travelled and were adapted, enriching the artistic vocabulary of each culture.

C. Milestones in Paubha History: Key Periods and Surviving Masterpieces

Several surviving masterpieces serve as crucial milestones in understanding the historical trajectory of Paubha art. The aforementioned 11th-century Paubha of Amitabha Buddha in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art remains a benchmark for early Paubha art.¹ Another significant early piece is a 13th-century depiction of Ratna Sambhava, also in the Los Angeles County Museum, further attesting to the antiquity and established quality of the art form.³ A 15th-century Vishnu Mandala is another example of a Hindu-themed Paubha from this formative period.¹

Stylistically, Newar art, including Paubha, underwent transformations over the centuries. For instance, by the 15th century, some Paubhas began to exhibit more elaborate archways and florid decorative tendencies, suggesting a shift towards a more “baroque” treatment compared to the earlier, perhaps more austere, styles.¹² This indicates an internal evolution of aesthetic preferences within the Newar artistic tradition.

The Paubha tradition, despite its periods of flourishing, also faced challenges. Towards the end of the Malla dynasty in the 18th century, political disturbances and instability led to a decline in patronage and, consequently, in the production and quality of Paubha paintings.⁸ However, the 20th century witnessed a significant renaissance of Paubha art, largely attributed to the pioneering efforts of artists such as Ananda Muni Shakya (1903-1944) and his son, Siddhi Muni Shakya (1932-2002).¹ These artists played a crucial role in re-establishing a distinctive style and revitalising the tradition for contemporary times.

The journey of Paubha art through time is marked by periods of intense creativity, external influences, and internal evolution. The scarcity of very early examples, due to the fragile nature of the cloth medium, the custom of ritual replacement of old paintings, and periods of political upheaval, makes each surviving piece exceptionally valuable.² These remnants offer precious glimpses into a rich artistic past and highlight the critical importance of ongoing efforts in conservation and documentation to safeguard this vulnerable heritage. Furthermore, the historical trajectory underscores the significant role of patronage. The flourishing of Paubha during the Malla period, fueled by royal, monastic, and mercantile support, contrasts sharply with its decline during times of instability, demonstrating a direct link between socio-political conditions, economic backing, and artistic vitality.⁸ The subsequent revival and adaptation of Paubha in the modern era, including its entry into the tourist market, represent new forms of patronage and cultural impetus that continue to shape its evolution.¹⁶

The Alchemy of Creation: Materials and Methods of Paubha Painting

The creation of a Paubha painting is a deeply spiritual and meticulous process, steeped in tradition and requiring immense skill, patience, and devotion. Each stage, from the preparation of the canvas to the final consecration, is performed with a sense of sacred purpose.

A. Preparing the Sacred Ground: The Canvas and Its Consecration

The foundation of a Paubha is a rectangular piece of cotton canvas, carefully selected and prepared to receive the sacred imagery.¹ While cotton is the most commonly cited material, historical accounts suggest that coarser cloth might have been used for Paubha compared to Tibetan Thangka, and some even mention the use of animal skin in earlier times.¹⁹

The preparation of the cotton canvas is a labour-intensive task that can take up to a week.⁸ The cloth is first stretched taut on a wooden frame. A special mixture of buffalo hide glue, known as ‘Saresh,’ and fine white clay, or ‘Sapeta,’ is then meticulously applied to the surface.¹ This coating fills the pores of the fabric and provides a smooth, receptive ground for the paint. After the coating dries, the surface is painstakingly burnished with a smooth stone, often repeatedly over several days, until it achieves a polished, almost leather-like finish.¹ This rigorous preparation ensures a durable and exceptionally smooth surface, essential for rendering the minute details and delicate lines that are hallmarks of Paubha art.

The entire process of creating a Paubha is imbued with ritual significance from its very inception. Before any artistic work begins, the creation is often initiated with prayers and blessings.⁶ A significant preliminary ritual is the ‘Hasta Puja’ (worship of the hands), performed by a Newar high priest, or ‘Gurju,’ on an auspiciously chosen day.² This ceremony serves to purify the artist’s body, mind, and speech, as well as the materials to be used, including the pigments and the canvas itself.² In some instances, the Gurju may inscribe a sacred syllable, a ‘bija mantra’ pertaining to the deity to be depicted, onto the canvas, officially sanctifying and commencing the painting process.² These initial rites underscore the understanding that Paubha creation is far more than an artistic endeavour; it is a profound spiritual act.

B. Colours of Devotion: Traditional Pigments and Their Significance

The soul-stirring beauty of Paubha paintings owes much to their distinctive palette, derived traditionally from natural mineral and plant sources.¹ Artists painstakingly grind these raw materials into fine powders to create their pigments, a process that itself can take months of manual labour to achieve the desired quality and consistency.⁸ The five elemental colours traditionally forming the core Paubha palette are red, blue, yellow, black, and white.⁸ Specific minerals are used to obtain these hues: lapis lazuli for rich blues, orpiment for vibrant yellows, cinnabar for deep reds, and finely ground conch shell powder for brilliant whites.²¹ Black pigment is typically derived from the soot of burning pine wood.²¹ These natural pigments not only contribute to the unique luminosity and depth of the colours but also ensure their remarkable longevity, allowing Paubhas to retain their vibrancy for centuries.⁶

Gold and silver are also integral to the Paubha palette, used extensively in powdered or leaf form to embellish the paintings.¹ These precious metals are often applied to highlight the ornaments of deities, the intricate patterns on their robes, or to create a divine aura around sacred figures, adding to the artwork’s richness, visual splendour, and spiritual value.⁶

The choice and application of colour in Paubha painting are far from arbitrary; they are governed by strict iconographic principles laid down in sacred texts.⁸ Each colour carries profound symbolic meaning, conveying specific attributes, energies, and aspects of the depicted deities or spiritual concepts. For instance, within the broader spectrum of Buddhist art, which informs Paubha, white is often associated with purity, peace, and longevity (as seen in depictions of White Tara); yellow can signify abundance, equanimity, or the earth element; blue may represent wisdom, truth, or the immutable nature of reality (Akshobhya Buddha); red is linked to power, subjugation, and the transformation of passion into wisdom (Amitabha Buddha); and green often denotes enlightened activity, balance, or nature (Green Tara).²² Paubha paintings are particularly noted for their use of deep, often subdued colours, with a characteristic prominence of rich reds and darker tones that contribute to their intense and contemplative quality.²

C. The Artist’s Hand: From Sketch to Soulful Detail

The execution of a Paubha painting is a testament to the artist’s discipline, skill, and deep understanding of sacred tradition. The entire painting process is strictly governed by rules of iconography, precise dimensions (iconometry), and compositional structures that have been handed down through generations.¹ Unlike many Western art forms, where individual creativity and originality are paramount, the traditional Paubha artist’s primary role is to faithfully render the divine according to these established canons. Free artistic expression, in the modern sense, is limited, as the paramount concern is the accurate and spiritually potent depiction of the deity or sacred diagram.¹ A profound knowledge of these iconographic and iconometric principles is therefore essential for any Paubha painter.⁸

The artistic process typically begins with a meticulous sketch of the composition, often based on textual descriptions or existing exemplars. This is followed by the careful application of initial coats of paint, then the principal layers of colour, intricate shading to create depth and volume, precise outlining to define forms, and finally, the application of gold or other embellishments.⁸ Paubha artists employ exceptionally delicate and fine brushes, sometimes as fine as ‘000’ gauge, to achieve the exquisite detail and subtle gradations of colour that are hallmarks of the style.⁸ Historically, these brushes were made with fine animal hairs, such as those from cats, goats, sables, or weasels, carefully bound to slender wooden handles, allowing for extraordinary precision.⁸

The creation of a Paubha was traditionally undertaken within a context of ritual purity and focused spiritual discipline. Artists were often expected to maintain a specific lifestyle during the painting process, which might include practices such as painting on an empty stomach, adhering to a strict vegetarian diet, and working in a quiet, secluded environment conducive to meditation and contemplation.² This disciplined approach, often undertaken with the guidance of a spiritual master or priest, was considered vital for channelling the necessary spiritual energy and focus required to create an image deemed sacred and powerful.⁸

D. “Opening the Eyes”: The Culmination of a Sacred Act (Mikhā Chāyekegu and other rituals)

One of the most crucial and spiritually significant moments in the creation of a Paubha painting is the ‘mikhā chāyekegu,’ or the “opening of the eyes” ceremony.¹ This pivotal act involves painting the eyes of the central deity, and it is performed only after all other elements of the painting have been completed.¹ This is not merely the final brushstroke but a profound ritual believed to infuse the image with life, transforming the painting from an inanimate object into a living embodiment of the deity’s presence and spiritual power.⁶ Through this ceremony, the image is consecrated and considered to possess spiritual properties, becoming a true icon fit for worship and meditation.⁸

Following the ‘mikhā chāyekegu’ and any other concluding consecration rites performed by a Bajracharya priest, the deity is considered to be “alive” and fully present within the Paubha.⁶ The painting is then ready to fulfil its sacred purpose. To complete the presentation, a decorative brocade border is often meticulously sewn around the edges of the canvas, serving as a frame and enhancing its visual appeal for display and veneration.¹

The entire journey of creating a Paubha, from the initial purification rituals and painstaking material preparation to the final, transformative “opening of the eyes,” underscores a profound worldview. The artist, by adhering to strict iconographic canons, maintaining ritual purity, and working with sanctified materials, acts less as an individual creator and more as a spiritual conduit.² Their skill is placed in the service of a sacred tradition, facilitating the manifestation of the divine. Even the materials themselves—the natural pigments, the precious metals, the carefully prepared canvas—are not inert substances but are treated as active participants in this sacred alchemy, chosen and prepared in ways that align with the devotional act and contribute to the painting’s overall sanctity.¹ The laborious grinding of minerals or the meticulous polishing of the canvas becomes, in themselves, acts of devotion.

Reading the Divine: Themes, Iconography, and Symbolism in Paubha

Paubha paintings are rich tapestries of meaning, where every line, colour, and figure contributes to a complex visual language rooted in Hindu and Buddhist philosophies. These artworks serve not only as objects of devotion but also as profound tools for spiritual instruction and contemplation.

A. A Pantheon on Cloth: Depicting Deities of Buddhist and Hindu Traditions

The thematic repertoire of Paubha art is vast, encompassing a wide array of subjects designed to cater to the diverse devotional and meditational needs of the Newar community.¹ Central to Paubha iconography is the depiction of deities from both the Buddhist and Hindu pantheons, reflecting the unique religious syncretism of the Kathmandu Valley.¹

Within the Buddhist tradition, Paubhas frequently feature images of various Buddhas, including the historical Shakyamuni Buddha, the celestial Amitabha Buddha, and the collective of the Pancha Buddhas (Five Wisdom Buddhas).¹ Bodhisattvas, embodying compassion and wisdom, are also prominent subjects. Among the most revered are forms of Tara, such as Green Tara, Arya Tara, and White Tara, each associated with specific enlightened activities and qualities.²⁴ Lokeshwor, the Newar Buddhist equivalent of Avalokiteshvara, the Bodhisattva of Compassion, is depicted in numerous forms, including Shimhanada Lokeshwor, Shadakshari Lokeshwor, and Amoghpasa Lokeshwor.²⁴ Other important Buddhist figures include Manjushree, the Bodhisattva of Wisdom, and Vajrapani, the Bodhisattva of Power, as well as various wrathful deities like Chandamaharosana, Vajrayogini, and Mahakala, who serve as protectors and transformers of negative energies.²⁴

From the Hindu pantheon, Paubha artists render deities such as Vishnu, often in the form of a Vishnu Mandala, which visually represents his cosmic domain.¹ Shiva, in his various aspects, including Mahadev and the fierce Bhairav (such as Kal Bhairava), is another common subject.²⁴ Ganesha, the remover of obstacles, Devi in her powerful forms like Mahisasura-mardini (the slayer of the buffalo demon), the goddess of learning Saraswati, the wealth goddess Lakshmi, and various Yoginis (female spiritual practitioners or goddesses) also feature prominently in Paubha art.²⁴

Mandalas are a particularly significant and recurrent theme in Paubha paintings.¹ These intricate geometric compositions are not merely decorative patterns but are profound spiritual diagrams representing the cosmos, the palace of a deity, or the enlightened mind itself. They serve as crucial aids for visualisation and meditation in Vajrayana Buddhist practice.⁵ Depictions of stupas or chaityas, sacred Buddhist monuments, are also popular subjects, symbolising the Buddha’s presence and the path to enlightenment.¹⁰

B. Narratives of Wisdom: Mythological Stories and Spiritual Teachings

Beyond iconic representations of deities, Paubha paintings often serve as visual narratives, illustrating sacred stories, mythological scenes, and the profound philosophies embedded in Hindu and Buddhist scriptures.⁶ These narrative Paubhas function as powerful teaching tools, making complex religious concepts and moral lessons accessible and memorable to a wider audience.⁵

A notable category of narrative Paubhas includes depictions of Avadana tales.³³ These are Buddhist parables, often related by the Buddha himself, that demonstrate the workings of karma (cause and effect) and extol the benefits of virtuous deeds. For example, the Suchandra Avadana, which recounts the story of a merchant’s wayward son who regains his fortune and spiritual merit through the worship of the wealth goddess Vasudhara, is frequently illustrated in Paubhas dedicated to this deity.³³ Similarly, the Swayambhu Purana, a sacred text detailing the mythological origins of the Swayambhunath Stupa and the Kathmandu Valley, provides rich narrative material for Paubha artists.²⁴ These story-based paintings are vital for moral instruction, reinforcing faith, and preserving cultural narratives.

While Jataka tales, which recount the previous lives of the Buddha, are a common theme in broader Buddhist art and particularly in Tibetan Thangkas, their specific prominence as central subjects in Newar Paubha paintings is less explicitly detailed in available resources compared to Avadanas or direct deity portrayals.³⁵ However, it is known that Newar artists were commissioned to paint Jataka murals in Tibetan monasteries, indicating their familiarity with these narratives.³⁵ Furthermore, the Newar artistic tradition does include narrative scrolls, such as those depicting scenes from the Svayambhupurana or the Hindu story of Ekadasivrata (a religious observance), which, while perhaps distinct in format from typical Paubhas, demonstrate a strong narrative impulse in Newar religious art.³⁶ Connections to Hindu epics like the Ramayana and Mahabharata can be inferred through the depiction of Hindu deities such as Rama (an avatar of Vishnu) and Garuda (the celestial mount of Vishnu) in Paubha art, though extensive narrative cycles from these epics are not a primary focus in the documented Paubha themes.³¹

C. The Language of Symbols: Understanding Colours, Mudras, and Attributes

Every element within a Paubha painting is laden with spiritual meaning and is meticulously arranged according to sacred iconometric proportions and compositional principles.⁶ The figures of deities are typically portrayed with serene or specific expressions and are characterised by distinct ‘mudras’ (symbolic hand gestures) that convey their particular qualities, such as compassion, wisdom, protection, or teaching.⁶ This codified visual language allows those familiar with the iconography to “read” the painting and understand the specific powers, teachings, and essence of the depicted divinity.

Colours, as previously discussed, are profoundly symbolic in Paubha art.⁵ The choice of colour for a deity’s body, aura, or garments is not arbitrary but is a key iconographic marker that defines their nature and energetic function. While Paubha paintings are often characterised by deep, somewhat subdued colours with a frequent dominance of red, the symbolic connotations of individual colours align with broader Buddhist and Hindu traditions.² For example, white may symbolise purity and peace (as in White Tara, who grants longevity), yellow can represent richness and equanimity (Ratnasambhava), blue often signifies the unchanging nature of reality and wisdom (Akshobhya), red is associated with power, magnetising energy, and the transformation of desires (Amitabha), and green typically denotes enlightened activity and protection (Green Tara).³

The attributes held by deities are also crucial iconographic symbols, visually communicating their identity, functions, and powers.⁶ A lotus flower typically represents purity and spiritual unfoldment, a ‘vajra’ (thunderbolt or diamond sceptre) symbolises spiritual power and indestructibility, a manuscript signifies wisdom (often the Prajnaparamita or Perfection of Wisdom texts), and an overflowing vase can denote abundance and spiritual nourishment.³³

Compositionally, Paubha paintings often feature a large, central deity placed within an ornate shrine or celestial palace, surrounded by smaller attendant figures, lineage gurus, or related deities arranged in hierarchical registers.¹ The background is frequently filled with stylised natural elements, such as abstract rock formations or clouds, rather than realistic landscapes.¹ Rules of symmetry and frontality (where figures face directly out of the painting) are commonly observed, contributing to the iconic and hieratic presence of the deities.¹⁹ This structured, hierarchical composition serves to emphasise the principal deity and create a clearly defined sacred space within the confines of the painting.

The intricate system of iconography in Paubha—encompassing colours, mudras, attributes, and composition—transforms each painting into a complex visual discourse or a form of “Dharma talk.” It is not merely a depiction of a deity but rather a visual encapsulation of that deity’s essential nature, their specific powers, and the profound philosophical concepts they embody.⁵ For a practitioner, engaging with a Paubha is akin to receiving sacred teachings, as each symbolic element, when understood, unlocks deeper layers of meaning related to spiritual principles and the path to enlightenment. The frequent depiction of mandalas is particularly telling in this regard.¹ These are not just aesthetically pleasing geometric designs but are understood as sacred maps of the cosmos and potent visual guides for the meditator’s inner journey towards spiritual realisation, providing a blueprint of the spiritual universe and a pathway to traverse from the mundane to the sacred.²

Paubha and Thangka: Kindred Spirits, Distinct Identities

Paubha paintings of Nepal and Thangka paintings of Tibet are often mentioned in the same breath, and indeed, they share a common heritage as sacred scroll paintings from the Himalayan region. Both serve as vital tools for Buddhist meditation, devotion, and instruction. However, despite their similarities in purpose and overall form, there are crucial distinctions in their iconography, style, and cultural context that give each tradition its unique identity.

A. Shared Roots and Sacred Purpose

At their core, both Paubha and Thangka are traditional religious paintings typically executed on cloth—cotton or silk—which are then often mounted on brocade fabric and designed to be rolled up for storage or transport.¹ The term “Paubha” is the Newari word for such a painted scroll, while “Thangka” is its Tibetan equivalent, both essentially meaning “painted scroll”.⁴¹ Their primary function is to serve as visual aids for spiritual practice, depicting deities, mandalas, spiritual lineage holders, or scenes from religious narratives, thereby helping practitioners to visualise complex spiritual concepts and connect with the divine.¹

Historical evidence strongly suggests that these two traditions share common origins, with Newar Paubha art playing a significant role in the early development of Tibetan Thangka.¹ Skilled Newar artists from the Kathmandu Valley travelled to Tibet, or their works were carried there by merchants and monks, introducing their styles and techniques, which were then adapted and evolved within the Tibetan cultural milieu.¹⁴ The fundamental materials and techniques also show considerable overlap: both traditions historically utilised cotton or silk canvases prepared with a ground of white clay or chalk mixed with an animal-based glue, and employed mineral and plant-based pigments as their primary colorants.¹⁹ This shared material culture and historical linkage underscore their status as kindred artistic expressions of Himalayan spirituality.

B. Distinguishing Features: Style, Iconography, and Cultural Context

Despite their shared ancestry and purpose, Paubha and Thangka have evolved along distinct paths, reflecting the unique cultural and religious environments of Nepal’s Kathmandu Valley and Tibet, respectively.

One of the most fundamental distinctions lies in their iconographic scope. Paubha paintings are unique in their inclusion of deities from both Hindu and Buddhist pantheons.¹ This reflects the remarkable religious symbiosis that has characterised the Newar culture of the Kathmandu Valley for centuries, where Hindu and Buddhist beliefs and practices have coexisted and often blended seamlessly.² In contrast, Tibetan Thangkas are predominantly Buddhist, although they may sometimes incorporate deities from the pre-Buddhist Bon religion of Tibet.¹ This “Hindu element” in Paubha is not merely an occasional feature but a defining characteristic that roots the art form firmly in the specific religious landscape of its origin, making it a visual testament to a unique cultural fusion not replicated in the same manner in purely Buddhist Thangkas.

Stylistically, there are also noticeable differences. Paubha art is often lauded for its exceptionally intricate details, precise and delicate linework, and highly stylised figures, which may feature elongated limbs and somewhat exaggerated facial features.² Early Nepalese Paubhas, in particular, are characterised by their exquisite rendering of details and often employ a colour palette that is deep and subdued, with a notable prominence of rich reds and darker shades.¹ While Thangkas also involve intricate detail, they are frequently characterised by more vibrant and extensive colour palettes, and often incorporate more elaborate scenic elements and landscapes in the background, creating a different visual atmosphere.² This contrast might suggest different aesthetic aims: Paubha’s meticulous detail and often more contained compositions, focusing on a central deity within a shrine-like structure with abstract backgrounds, can evoke a sense of focused, inward intensity suitable for deep contemplation.¹ Thangka, with its capacity for broader, more vibrant depictions of sacred realms and narrative landscapes, might offer a more expansive visual and spiritual engagement.

In terms of materials, while both use cotton or silk, some sources suggest that traditional Paubha artists may have used a coarser type of cloth compared to that typically used for Thangkas, which could subtly affect the texture and application of paint.³

The cultural origin and evolution are also distinct. Paubha is an art form indigenous to the Newar community of the Kathmandu Valley and is considered a pinnacle of Newar artistic achievement.¹ The Thangka tradition, while influenced by Newar art, is primarily associated with the cultural and religious context of central Tibet and its various monastic orders.²

Regarding artistic freedom, while both traditions are bound by strict iconographic rules for the depiction of deities, some observers note that modern Paubha artists may exhibit more room for personal expression and innovation in composition, especially when compared to the more rigidly canonical approach often seen in traditional Thangka painting, where creativity might be more confined to decorative elements like landscape details.¹⁹ However, it is important to note that traditional Paubha painting itself was highly rule-bound.¹

The following table provides a concise comparison of these key features:

Table: Paubha vs. Tibetan Thangka – A Comparative Overview

Understanding these distinctions is crucial for appreciating the unique cultural contributions of both Paubha and Thangka art, recognising them as related yet independent streams within the rich river of Himalayan sacred art.

Paubha in the Contemporary World: Evolution and Adaptation

The ancient tradition of Paubha painting, far from being a static relic of the past, continues to evolve and find new expression in the contemporary world. Modern artists, while often deeply rooted in traditional techniques and iconography, are also engaging with new materials, styles, and a global audience, ensuring the art form’s continued vitality.

A. Pioneers of Modernity: Artists Bridging Past and Present

The 20th century marked a significant period of revival and modernisation for Paubha art, spearheaded by visionary artists. Anandamuni Shakya (1903-1944) is widely recognised as a pivotal figure who infused Paubha with a contemporary sensibility.¹ While respecting the core religious symbolism, he began to incorporate elements of Western-style realistic expression into his works, giving them a fresh, dynamic quality.¹ His son, Siddhimuni Shakya (1932-2002), continued this innovative legacy, further contributing to the renaissance of Paubha painting.¹⁴

Following in this innovative stream, contemporary artists like Udaya Charan Shrestha (born 1964) have gained international acclaim for their mastery in blending traditional Paubha principles with modern artistic approaches.¹ Shrestha, deeply versed in Newar rituals and daily life, creates dynamic compositions, often utilising oil paints and incorporating contemporary elements such as modern jewellery designs into his depictions of deities.¹ He is celebrated for his ability to design original compositions while maintaining the stringent iconographic accuracy required by the tradition.⁴⁴

The contemporary Paubha scene is vibrant, with numerous other artists making significant contributions. Raj Prakash Tuladhar is known for his meticulous study of deities, his exceptionally unique colour combinations, and the international recognition his work has garnered.²⁹ Lok Chitrakar, a largely self-taught artist, emphasises precise iconography based on ancient texts and masterfully blends classical techniques with contemporary influences; he is also actively involved in teaching and mentoring younger artists.⁹ Artists such as Rabi Shrestha and Ujay Bajracharya, the latter also an author and faculty member at a traditional art college, further exemplify the dedication and skill that characterise today’s leading Paubha painters.² These individuals, and many others, are crucial in carrying the lineage of Paubha art forward, acting as both custodians of tradition and agents of its evolution.

B. Innovations in Tradition: New Styles, Materials, and Expressions

Contemporary Paubha artists, while respecting the sacred core of the tradition, have not shied away from exploring new artistic avenues. One of the most noticeable innovations is the diversification of materials. While traditional Paubhas relied exclusively on natural mineral and plant pigments, some modern artists experiment with oil paints, acrylics, and even poster colours.¹ This shift allows for different textural effects and, in some cases, a broader range of hues, though many artists still prefer traditional pigments for their unique luminosity and spiritual significance.²⁴

There is also a discernible evolution in style and composition. While traditional Paubha painting offered limited scope for individual creativity, with artists primarily functioning as faithful reproducers of canonical forms, some contemporary masters like Udaya Charan Shrestha are known for designing their own original compositions.¹ This involves a creative reinterpretation of traditional layouts and a more dynamic presentation of figures, often imbuing them with a contemporary sensuality or psychological depth while strictly adhering to the essential iconographic attributes of the deities.⁴⁴ Raj Prakash Tuladhar, for example, is noted for his distinctive and innovative use of colour combinations.²⁹

The status of the artist and the artwork has also subtly shifted. Traditionally, Paubhas were unsigned and undated, their creation considered an act of devotion rather than a display of personal artistic prowess.¹ In the contemporary art world, however, Paubha paintings are increasingly recognised as fine art, and artists are gaining individual recognition. Their works are exhibited in galleries and museums worldwide and can command significant prices in the international art market, reflecting a change in perception where the artist’s skill and unique vision are acknowledged alongside the work’s spiritual value.²⁴ This evolution presents a dynamic interplay: innovation keeps the art form relevant and engaging for new generations and diverse audiences, yet it also navigates a delicate balance with the profound spiritual intent and rigorous discipline that have historically defined Paubha. The use of modern materials or stylistic adaptations, if not thoughtfully integrated, could be perceived by some as a departure from the art form’s sacred essence, highlighting an ongoing dialogue within the tradition about authenticity and evolution.

C. Paubha Today: From Sacred Spaces to Global Galleries

In the contemporary era, Paubha art occupies a multifaceted role. It continues to be deeply embedded in the religious and spiritual life of the Newar community in Nepal. Paubhas are still commissioned for worship, displayed during important religious festivals such as the Gunla Parva (a holy month for Newar Buddhists), and used as focal points for meditation and devotional practices in homes and monasteries.¹ This enduring traditional function underscores its continued relevance as a living sacred art.

Simultaneously, Paubha painting has transcended its original geographical and cultural confines to achieve significant international recognition.⁶ Works by Newar artists are sought after by art collectors, spiritual practitioners, and cultural institutions across the globe. Museums such as the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, the Fukuoka Asian Art Museum in Japan, and the Robert Beer Museum in the UK house important Paubha paintings, showcasing this unique Nepali heritage to a wider audience.¹ This global exposure has led to the commercialisation of Paubha art, with paintings being sold in tourist areas like Thamel in Kathmandu and fetching substantial prices in the international art market.¹⁶

This entry into the global art market presents both opportunities and challenges. On one hand, it provides vital economic sustenance for artists and their families, encourages the continuation of the craft, and promotes Nepali culture on an international stage.¹⁶ On the other hand, commercial pressures can sometimes lead to the production of works tailored more to tourist tastes than to traditional iconographic or spiritual depth, potentially resulting in a dilution of quality or authenticity if not carefully managed.¹⁷ The demand for quicker production to meet market needs can also conflict with the time-consuming, meticulous nature of traditional Paubha creation. Thus, the global market acts as a complex force, capable of both elevating and potentially compromising this ancient art form, necessitating a careful balance between artistic integrity, spiritual purpose, and economic realities.

Preserving a Precious Heritage: Challenges and Future Directions

The enduring legacy of Paubha painting, while vibrant, faces a confluence of challenges that threaten its continuity. However, dedicated efforts from artists, cultural institutions, and communities are actively working towards its preservation and promotion, navigating the complexities of maintaining an ancient tradition in the modern world.

A. The Fragile Legacy: Threats to Paubha Art

One of the most tangible threats to Paubha’s heritage is art theft. Many ancient Paubhas have been illicitly removed from monasteries, temples, and private collections in Nepal, ending up in international art markets or private collections abroad.¹ This has led to a sense of caution, resulting in fewer and shorter traditional public exhibitions of valuable pieces.¹ While repatriation efforts are underway and have seen some success, the loss of these cultural treasures from their original contexts is significant.⁴⁸

Beyond physical loss, there is concern about the erosion of the intangible heritage associated with Paubha creation. The strict ritualistic practices, the disciplined lifestyle of the artist, and the deep spiritual intent that traditionally accompanied the painting process are not always maintained in contemporary practice.² Paintings are sometimes created more for commercial purposes than for religious devotion, which can alter the profound spiritual depth inherent in traditionally produced Paubhas.⁸

Practical challenges also abound for artists wishing to adhere to traditional methods. Sourcing authentic traditional materials, such as specific mineral pigments, can be difficult and expensive.⁸ The creation of a true Paubha is an intensely time-consuming and laborious process, requiring months or even years for a single complex piece, which can be economically challenging in a fast-paced market.⁸

The economic viability of Paubha artists is a persistent concern. They face competition from mass-produced prints and lower-quality replicas that flood the tourist market at cheaper prices.¹⁷ The market can also be heavily dependent on tourism, where artists may receive only a small fraction of the final sale price, with significant commissions going to intermediaries.¹⁷ Furthermore, a perceived lack of consistent governmental support and recognition for traditional arts can hinder broader development.²⁹ This economic pressure, coupled with the demanding nature of the art form, has led to a declining interest among some younger generations in pursuing Paubha painting as a lifelong career.¹⁷ Finally, a lack of clear distinction and awareness in the global market between Paubha and the more widely known Tibetan Thangka can limit the recognition of Paubha’s unique Nepali identity and its specific cultural value.¹⁷

B. Guardians of the Art: Efforts in Conservation and Promotion

Despite these challenges, a dedicated community of artists, scholars, and cultural organisations is actively working to preserve and promote Paubha art. Individual artists, such as those previously mentioned, like Lok Chitrakar, Udaya Charan Shrestha, and Raj Prakash Tuladhar, are at the forefront of this movement.⁴⁴ Through their exceptional artwork, their commitment to teaching and mentoring new artists, and their advocacy for the tradition, they serve as vital guardians of this heritage.²

Educational institutions are playing an increasingly important role. Art schools and colleges in Nepal, such as the Aksheswar Traditional Buddhist Art College and Sirjana College of Fine Arts, now offer specialised courses in Paubha painting.² These programs provide systematic training in the requisite skills, techniques, iconographic knowledge, underlying philosophy, and even the commercial aspects of the art, helping to cultivate a new generation of knowledgeable practitioners.² Workshops and seminars, sometimes led by master artists, also offer opportunities for intensive learning.⁴⁶

Museums, both within Nepal (like the Museum of Nepali Art – MONA, the National Museum of Nepal, and the community-driven Itumbaha Museum) and internationally, contribute significantly by exhibiting, researching, and preserving Paubha paintings.²⁹ These institutions act as crucial repositories of cultural heritage and serve as platforms for public education and appreciation.

Governmental bodies, such as Nepal’s Department of Archaeology, are involved in efforts to recover and repatriate stolen artifacts, including Paubhas.⁴⁸ Historically, there have been governmental policies aimed at promoting traditional arts, though the consistency and impact of such support can vary.¹⁴

A growing number of non-governmental and international organisations are also contributing to the cause. Bodies like the Himalayan Art Council, the Kathmandu Valley Preservation Trust (which has been instrumental in projects like the restoration of Itumbaha monastery and its museum), the Rubin Museum of Art in New York, and community groups such as Newa Guthi are involved in diverse initiatives.⁴⁹ These efforts range from supporting conservation projects and facilitating repatriation to promoting Paubha art through exhibitions and publications, and even exploring innovative technological solutions, such as the use of AI and blockchain for authentication and provenance tracking, to protect the integrity of the artworks and support artists.⁴⁹

C. The Living Tradition: Nurturing Paubha for Generations to Come

Paubha painting is not merely a historical artifact; it remains a vibrant, living tradition deeply interwoven with the spiritual and cultural fabric of the Newar community.³ Its continued practice in religious rituals, festivals, and personal devotion attests to its enduring relevance and spiritual potency.⁶ The future of this precious art form likely lies in a dynamic balance between honouring and preserving its profound traditions while embracing thoughtful innovation that allows it to resonate with contemporary audiences.⁴⁶

The increasing global interest in Paubha art, while presenting challenges, also offers exciting opportunities for new dialogues, creative collaborations, and broader cultural exchange.¹⁷ This can help to ensure that the intricate skills and deep spiritual wisdom embodied in Paubha continue to be transmitted to future generations. One particularly promising avenue for sustainable preservation may lie in community-led initiatives, exemplified by the successful efforts of the Itumbaha Monastery community in Kathmandu.⁴⁹ Supported by external organisations, the local custodians of this heritage took the lead in preserving their artifacts and establishing a museum, demonstrating a powerful model of grassroots conservation that ensures cultural sensitivity and long-term local ownership.⁴⁹ Such approaches, which empower the communities who are the hereditary keepers of these traditions, can be highly effective in safeguarding both the tangible artworks and the intangible knowledge they represent.

Furthermore, the thoughtful integration of modern technology, such as the use of AI and blockchain for authenticating artworks and tracing their provenance, offers a novel way to address critical issues like art theft, forgeries, and the proliferation of mass-produced replicas.¹⁷ These tools can help protect the integrity and market value of authentic Paubha paintings, provide greater security and recognition for artists, and educate a global audience about the genuine characteristics of this ancient art. By bridging ancient practices with contemporary solutions, such initiatives can play a crucial role in ensuring that Paubha art not only survives but thrives, continuing to inspire awe and devotion for generations to come.

Conclusion: The Enduring Spirit of Paubha

Paubha painting stands as a profound testament to the artistic genius and deep spiritual heritage of the Newar people of Nepal’s Kathmandu Valley. More than mere decoration, each Paubha is a sacred object, a meticulously crafted tool for meditation, and a vibrant expression of cultural identity, embodying centuries of devotion and artistic skill.¹ Its historical journey, from ancient origins possibly in the Licchavi period through the flourishing Malla era to its contemporary manifestations, reveals a tradition that has both steadfastly preserved its core tenets and demonstrated a remarkable capacity for adaptation and exchange with neighbouring cultures like India and Tibet.²

The creation of a Paubha is an alchemical process, where natural materials are transformed through ritual and painstaking labour into a conduit for the divine.² The strict adherence to iconographic rules, the symbolic language of colours, mudras, and attributes, and the culminating “opening of the eyes” ceremony all underscore the painting’s primary role as a sacred entity, a visual Dharma talk designed to guide the practitioner towards spiritual understanding.¹ While sharing roots with Tibetan Thangka, Paubha maintains its distinct identity through its unique embrace of both Hindu and Buddhist iconography, its characteristic stylistic nuances, and its deep connection to the specific cultural milieu of the Newar people.¹

In the modern era, Paubha art navigates a dynamic interplay between tradition and innovation. Contemporary artists continue to push creative boundaries, exploring new materials and personal expressions while often remaining anchored to the art form’s spiritual foundations.¹ This evolution has brought Paubha to global audiences, fostering international appreciation but also presenting challenges related to commercialisation, authenticity, and the preservation of traditional practices.¹⁵

The threats to this precious heritage—from art theft and the erosion of ritual knowledge to economic pressures on artists—are significant.¹ Yet, the concerted efforts of dedicated artists, cultural institutions, scholars, and community organisations offer hope for its future.⁴⁶ Through education, conservation, ethical promotion, and the empowerment of local custodians, the living tradition of Paubha painting can be nurtured. By safeguarding this unique artistic and spiritual legacy, future generations will continue to have access to a profound source of beauty, wisdom, and connection to Nepal’s rich cultural tapestry, ensuring that the enduring spirit of Paubha continues to illuminate the path of devotion and understanding.

Disclaimer

This article is based on an analysis of provided research snippets and aims to offer a comprehensive overview of Paubha paintings. The information presented reflects the content and interpretations derived from these sources. For in-depth academic research or specialised study, readers are encouraged to consult primary scholarly works, engage directly with experts in Himalayan and Newar art, and visit collections housing these artworks. The portrayal of complex cultural and religious practices within this article is undertaken with the utmost respect and strives for accuracy based on the available material.

Reference

1. Paubha – Wikipedia, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paubha
2. Preserving Paubha art – Inside Himalayas, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.insidehimalayas.com/preserving-paubha-art/
3. Paubha Painting: A Visual Delight from Nepal – Rooftop, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://rooftopapp.com/blogs/paubha-painting-a-visual-delight-from-nepal
4. risingnepaldaily.com, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://risingnepaldaily.com/news/61297#:~:text=Paubha%20art%20holds%20profound%20cultural,of%20a%20deeply%20rooted%20civilisation.
5. The Spiritual Significance of Paubha Art: Connecting Through Paintings – Typical Art, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://typicalartnepal.com/blog/the-spiritual-significance-of-paubha-art-connecting-through-paintings
6. Paubha Painting: The Sacred Newari Art of Nepal – Himalayan Mart, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://himalayanmart.com/blogs/news/paubha-painting-the-sacred-newari-art-of-nepal
7. Paubha｜Art Terms｜Knowing｜Asian Art Resource Room, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://asianart-gateway.jp/en/knowing/term/1819/
8. Paubha Painting: The Traditional Art of Nepal – Arts of Nepal, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://artsofnepal.com/blog/post/paubha-painting-the-traditional-art-of-nepal.html
9. Lok Chitrakar – Arts of Nepal, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://artsofnepal.com/artists/1-lok-chitrakar
10. Paubha Art – Pride of Newars – Spaces Blog – WordPress.com, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://spacesnepalblog.wordpress.com/2018/06/26/paubha-art-pride-of-newars/
11. 1stbuddha Newar Buddhist Art from Nepal | Kathmandu Valley Masterpieces, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.1stbuddha.com/en/newar-art-tradition
12. Nepalese Painting – The Metropolitan Museum of Art, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.metmuseum.org/essays/nepalese-painting
13. Newar architecture – Wikipedia, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newar_architecture
14. Jewels of Newar Art 2011 – Catalog -, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://bodhisattvainternational.com/product/jewels-of-newar-art-2011-catalog/
15. Paubha: Nepal’s Sacred Painting Tradition – Art Blog – The Art Life Gallery, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.theartlifegallery.com/blog/paubha-nepals-sacred-painting-tradition/
16. Nepali Tourism: How Cultural Heritage Shapes the Industry – The Wonder Nepal, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://thewondernepal.com/articles/nepali-tourism-how-cultural-heritage-shapes-the-industry/
17. Economy of Thangka: From Sacred Art to Global Commerce – Nepal Economic Forum, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://nepaleconomicforum.org/economy-of-thangka-from-sacred-art-to-global-commerce/
18. Paubha Painting Training – Nepal HandiCraft Design, accessed on May 20, 2025, http://www.nepalhandicraftdesign.org.np/traning/58-Paubha%20Painting%20Training
19. Sacred Paintings/ Thangkas and Paubhas of Nepal – Asia InCH, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.asiainch.org/craft/sacred-paintingsthangkas-paubhas/
20. Art that Moves You: Meeting Paubha Master Artist Udaya Charan Shrestha – ecs nepal, accessed on May 20, 2025, http://ecs.com.np/craft-maker/art-that-moves-you-meeting-paubha-master-artist-udaya-charan-shrestha
21. Nepal’s Buddhist Art – Royal Mountain Travel || For Tours & Treks in Nepal, Tibet & Bhutan, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://royalmt.com.np/new-blogs/nepals-buddhist-art/
22. Color Symbolism in Buddhist Art | PDF | Mandala | Yellow – Scribd, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://ro.scribd.com/document/134630668/Color-Symbolism-in-Buddhist-Art
23. Types of Thangka Paintings : Sacred Tibetan Art | Boudha Stupa Thanka, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://bstcthanka.com/blogs/thangka/what-you-need-to-know-about-types-of-thangka-paintings
24. Shrestha Immersed In Paubha Legacy – The Rising Nepal, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://risingnepaldaily.com/news/61297
25. The Sacred Art of Nepal – Paubha – Inside Himalayas, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.insidehimalayas.com/the-sacred-art-of-nepal-paubha/
26. Types of Brushes used in Tibetan Art – Construction and its maintenance – Mandalas Life, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://mandalas.life/2018/types-of-brushes-used-in-tibetan-art-construction-and-its-maintenance/
27. TK- NEWARI | Newari Paubha, , The painting, , – Handmade Handicraft, accessed on May 20, 2025, http://www.handmadeexpo.com/client/index.php?action=showiconographySingle&icon_id=259
28. eye-opening ceremony | Dictionary of Buddhism, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.nichirenlibrary.org/en/dic/Content/E/109
29. Paubha Painting: Authenticity To Nepali Art – The Rising Nepal, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://risingnepaldaily.com/news/21956
30. Lakṣacaitya paubhās. Pictorial representations of a Newar Buddhist ritual performance, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://journals.openedition.org/emscat/6487
31. Painting on Hindu Themes – National Museum of Asian Art, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://asia.si.edu/explore-art-culture/collections/search/edanmdm:fsg_S1999.2/
32. Unique Arts of Nepal, Painting, Sculpture, Textile, Pottery, Wood Carving – Altitude Himalaya, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.altitudehimalaya.com/blog/unique-arts-of-nepal
33. A LARGE AND RARE PAINTING OF A VASUDHARA MANDALA, NEPAL, 14TH-15TH CENTURY | Christie’s, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-6416992
34. A PAUBHA OF VASUDHARA NEPAL, 14TH/15TH CENTURY – Bonhams, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.bonhams.com/auction/30129/lot/734/a-paubha-of-vasudhara-nepal-14th15th-century/
35. Mural Painting at Zhalu Monastery | Project Himalayan Art – Rubin Museum, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://rubinmuseum.org/projecthimalayanart/essays/mural-painting-at-zhalu-monastery/
36. Narrative Scroll depicting Scenes from the Svayambhupurana (Primary Title) – (91.466) – Collections – Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://vmfa.museum/piction/6027262-8171851/
37. Lot 73 – A LONG NARRATIVE SCROLL EXTOLLING – Olympia Auctions, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.olympiaauctions.com/auction/lot/73-a-long-narrative-scroll-extolling-ekadasivrata/?lot=30225&sd=1
38. The Garuda Bird Paubha Painting Print | The Mythical Creature – Enlightenment Thangka, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://enlightenmentthangka.com/products/the-garuda-bird
39. The Spiritual Significance of Thangka Paintings in Meditation – Folk Canvas, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://folkcanvas.com/states-of-india/spiritual-significance-of-thangka/
40. Sacred Paintings/ Thangkas and Paubhas of Nepal – Asia InCH, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://asiainch.org/craft/sacred-paintingsthangkas-paubhas/
41. Pauba – A Contemporary Newari “Thangka” | Thangka Mandala, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.thangka-mandala.com/blog/pauba-vajrasattva/
42. History and Evolution of Thangka Painting – Boudha Stupa Thanka Center, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://bstcthanka.com/blogs/thangka/history-of-thangka
43. Tantric Art: Then And Now – Tricycle: The Buddhist Review, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://tricycle.org/magazine/tantric-art-then-and-now/
44. Udaya Charan Shrestha | Artist – Mahakala Fine Arts, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://mahakalafinearts.com/collections/udaya-charan-shrestha
45. Uday Charan Shrestha – Asian Art at Asianart.com, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.asianart.com/exhibitions/nan/bios/031.html
46. High Quality Newari Paubha Paintings in Nepal – Simrik Atelier, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://simrikatelier.com/high-quality-newari-paubha-paintings/
47. Packaging the Naked Buddhas – OpenEdition Journals, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://journals.openedition.org/ateliers/10263?lang=en
48. Back where they belong | Nepali Times, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://nepalitimes.com/news/back-where-they-belong
49. What Happens When Precious Newari Paintings Go to Kathmandu?, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://culturalpropertynews.org/precious-newari-paintings-go-to-kathmandu/
50. Raj Prakash Man Tuladhar – Kathmandu Art House, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://ktmgh.com/kah/raj-prakash-man-tuladhar/
51. Conservation of Traditional and Contemporary Thangka and Pauba – ICCROM, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.iccrom.org/classifieds/event/conservation-traditional-and-contemporary-thangka-and-pauba
52. Nepal’s Sacred Art Gets Tech Boost with New Exhibition Launch – CoinTrust, accessed on May 20, 2025, https://www.cointrust.com/market-news/nepals-sacred-art-gets-tech-boost-with-new-exhibition-launch